Murder at the Oaklands Mansion by Melinda Richarz Lyons, illustrations by Charisse Richarz
TreasureLine Publishing, 2012. 978-1617521317
Synopsis: Brooks Martin and his Aunt Mandy love having adventures – the more wild and daring the better! They also love history and trivia, especially about their hometown of Murfreesboro, Tennessee. When a Civil War reenactor is shot and his last words are to Brooks, Brooks and Aunt Mandy find themselves determined to solve the mystery of his death and his incoherent mutterings. Can they get to the bottom of the case or will they be dismissed as “just a kid and an old lady”?
Why I picked it up: The combination of historical fiction and murder mystery was something I didn’t want to pass up.
Why I finished it: This is a delightful read for both middle graders and their families. It highlights the strong bond between a young boy and his eccentric great aunt, and the love that they have for pushing themselves to be better and better. They have a thirst for knowledge that sometimes leads them into super crazy situations. I was instantly endeared to these characters and the relationships that continue to build as the plot moves along. I liked that the story kept up a steady pace throughout that made it easy to follow along and put together the clues alongside Brooks and Aunt Mandy. And I loved that Lyons devotes a couple of chapters to a research session in the library. Plus, it highlights the fun of knowing local history and exploring the towns in which we live, even if they might not be as historically exciting as Murfreesboro. The book may seem somewhat simplistic, but this makes it ideal for reluctant and struggling readers to read by themselves or out loud. It’s an intriguing, nail-biting read that will keep readers hooked and hoping for more.
Other related materials: Cynthia’s Attic series by Mary Cunningham; The Westing Game by Ellen Raskin; Encyclopedia Brown books by Donald J. Sobol; Nancy Drew books by Carolyn Keene; Nancy Drew and the Clue Crew book by Carolyn Keene, illustrated by Macky Pamintuan; The Hardy Boys books by Fanklin W. Dixon; The Boxcar Children series by Gertrude Chandler Warner; Nate the Great books by Marjorie Weinman Sharmat, illustrated by Marc Simont; The Samantha Wolf Mysteries series by Tara Ellis, illustrated by Melchelle Designs; Escape from Mr. Lemoncello’s Library by Chris Grabenstein; Mr. Lemoncello’s Library Olympics by Chris Grabenstein; The Book Scavenger series by Jennifer Chambliss Bertman; When You Reach Me by Rebecca Stead